Does Gatsby's at The Grand Resort serve real Wagyu?

Yes, and it says where the beef comes from. Gatsby's at The Grand Resort in Warren, OH publishes enough detail on its own materials to identify the Wagyu it sells, which is the standard this directory calls verified, last checked on August 17, 2026. That means a named Japanese brand or prefecture with its grade, an American breed status with a named producer, or an Australian producer with a marbling score.

What kind of Wagyu does Gatsby's at The Grand Resort serve?

Its menu discloses Carney Wagyu Cattle Ranch (Southington, Ohio). Each of those is taken from the venue's own current materials rather than from a review or a listing site, and the evidence behind it is quoted further down this page.

How was Gatsby's at The Grand Resort verified?

By reading the venue's own current material, its menu, its site or its ordering system, and quoting the line that names the beef. Reviews, aggregator copies and press mentions are not accepted as the source, because they go stale silently. Verification is assisted by AI and every claim is stored with the page it came from, last confirmed on August 17, 2026.

● American Wagyu - Fullblood

Gatsby's at The Grand Resort

Name: Gatsby's at The Grand Resort
Address: 9519 E Market St, Warren, OH, 44484, US
Telephone: (330) 609-8814
Price range: $$$$

Warren, OH · American

Tier 2 · Provenance-Transparent What the tiers mean

View menu Website

Why it's listed

The fine dining room at The Grand Resort in Warren, open Wednesday to Saturday from 5 pm and bookable on OpenTable. At the head of its Prime Steaks list is the Chef's Wagyu Selection at market price, a cut that changes weekly. The menu prints it as locally raised and sourced from Carney's Wagyu Cattle Ranch in Southington, Ohio, 100% Full-Blooded Wagyu. One line gives origin, producer and breed status together, which is the whole American Wagyu standard. The ranch's own site names Gatsby's as a customer, so both sides of the claim agree.

Authenticity flags

The Wagyu is a rotating weekly selection sold at market price. No cut and no price are printed, so ask which cut is on and what it costs before you order.
This is Wagyu raised in Ohio, not beef imported from Japan. The ranch is 30 miles from the resort and the menu says so plainly, but there is no Japanese grade on the card and none should be expected.

Wagyu on the menu

American
Brand / Prefecture
Not listed
Grade
Not listed
Producer
Carney Wagyu Cattle Ranch (Southington, Ohio)

Origin	Brand / Prefecture	Grade	Producer
American	Not listed	Not listed	Carney Wagyu Cattle Ranch (Southington, Ohio)

The experience

Butcher shop

New to these? Ways to eat Wagyu

Sourced from

Carney Wagyu Cattle Ranch (Southington, Ohio)farm ↗

Evidence on file

“Prime Steaks / served with a garden salad and accompaniment / CHEF'S WAGYU SELECTION . . . . MP / ask your server for this week's Wagyu selection / • locally raised and sourced from Carney's Wagyu Cattle Ranch in Southington, Ohio / • 100% Full-Blooded Wagyu”
avalongcc.com
“Our Certifications / Every member of the Carney herd is certified 100% full-blood Wagyu by the American Wagyu Association, the industry's recognized oversight authority for classifying, registering and certifying Wagyu cattle, and promoting Wagyu beef in the United States and...”
carneywagyu.com
“Our Breeding Program / All of our cattle are authentic Wagyu – unlike so-called American Wagyu, which is crossbred with Angus or other cattle breeds. / Every member of our herd is traceable to five generations, raised using traditional practices in modern facilities.”
carneywagyu.com

+5 more quotes on file

“Proudly Featured At ... <a class="partner partner-link" href="https://www.thegrandresort.com/resort-gatsbys/"><img src="https://carneywagyu.com/hs-fs/hubfs/GatsbysBlackMartiniGlass.png" alt="GatsbysBlackMartiniGlass"></a> ... Local: Based in Southington, Ohio – 30 miles...”
carneywagyu.com
“CHEF'S WAGYU SELECTION / ask your server for this weeks Wagyu selection / • locally raised and sourced from Carney's Wagyu Cattle Ranch in Southington, Ohio / • 100% Full-Blooded Wagyu”
web.archive.org
“14 OZ STRIP STEAK. . . . 65 / 16 OZ RIBEYE. . . . 65 / 8 OZ FILET. . . . 65 / 6 OZ FILET. . . . 55 / PRIME STEAK ADDITIONS / sautéed bell peppers 5 | sautéed mushrooms 4.5 | onions 3.25 | crumbled bleu 3 | gorgonzola cream sauce 3”
avalongcc.com
“<a target="_blank" href="https://www.avalongcc.com/dining/GatsbyMenu2026.pdf">Gatsby’s Menu</a>”
thegrandresort.com
“Restaurants & Hours ... Gatsby's / Wednesday & Thursday 5pm-10pm / Friday & Saturday 5pm-11pm ... For reservations, call (330) 856-1900 or book online. ... 9519 East Market Street, Warren, OH 44484 ... © 2026 The Grand Resort.”
thegrandresort.com

Quoted from the sources checked when this listing was verified.

Address

9519 E Market St · Warren, OH 44484Get directions See Warren on the Wagyu map →

Phone

(330) 609-8814

Price

Last verified

August 17, 2026 · evidence on file

Something wrong with this restaurant? Tell us

Common questions

Does Gatsby's at The Grand Resort serve real Wagyu?: Yes, and it says where the beef comes from. Gatsby's at The Grand Resort in Warren, OH publishes enough detail on its own materials to identify the Wagyu it sells, which is the standard this directory calls verified, last checked on August 17, 2026. That means a named Japanese brand or prefecture with its grade, an American breed status with a named producer, or an Australian producer with a marbling score.
What kind of Wagyu does Gatsby's at The Grand Resort serve?: Its menu discloses Carney Wagyu Cattle Ranch (Southington, Ohio). Each of those is taken from the venue's own current materials rather than from a review or a listing site, and the evidence behind it is quoted further down this page.
How was Gatsby's at The Grand Resort verified?: By reading the venue's own current material, its menu, its site or its ordering system, and quoting the line that names the beef. Reviews, aggregator copies and press mentions are not accepted as the source, because they go stale silently. Verification is assisted by AI and every claim is stored with the page it came from, last confirmed on August 17, 2026.